Blog

Why It's Nonsense

According to traditional acupuncture theory, energy flows through the body along pathways called meridians. The needles are supposed to release blockages and restore balance. The problem is that nobody has demonstrated the existence of these meridians or the kind of energy acupuncture practitioners are talking about.

That doesn't automatically tell us whether someone can feel better after a session. But it certainly gives us no reason to accept the explanation behind it. If acupuncture works for a particular condition, it should be possible to demonstrate that with properly controlled studies, not just stories about blocked energy.

Placebo Effect

One possible reason people feel better is the placebo effect. Expectations, attention and the whole treatment ritual can influence how symptoms are experienced, especially pain. Some people also feel better over time regardless of what treatment they receive. That's why anecdotes like 'I tried acupuncture and my back stopped hurting' aren't enough to prove that the needles did anything specific.

I don't like it when treatments with uncertain benefits are advertised as if they can cure practically everything. It's particularly dangerous if someone chooses them instead of getting a serious health problem checked by a doctor. Feeling a little relief is one thing. Delaying effective medical care is another.

Risks of Acupuncture

There are risks too. Poorly sterilized needles can cause infections, and incorrect needle placement can injure tissue or cause bleeding. In rare cases, needles have even caused a collapsed lung (pneumothorax). That doesn't mean every session ends in disaster, of course, but it does mean acupuncture isn't completely harmless.

Closing Words

I'm not convinced by talk of meridians, energy blockages or needles that somehow bring the body back into balance. Claims like these need evidence, and the traditional explanation simply doesn't have it. If you're dealing with a medical problem, I'd rather see you rely on proper diagnosis and evidence-based treatment than on esoteric promises.